OpenPyXL vs Pandas: Comparing Data Porting and Analysis

OpenPyXL vs Pandas: Key Differences

When to Use OpenPyXL

• Excel Formatting: When you need to manipulate Excel-specific features like styling, charts, or pivot tables.
• Template Generation: When you are building Excel templates with specific formats and layouts.
• Small to Medium Data: If you are working with small datasets and need granular control over formatting and structure.

When to Use Pandas

• Data Analysis: For complex data analysis, including filtering, grouping, pivoting, and aggregating large datasets.
• Large Datasets: When working with large datasets that need to be read, manipulated, and analyzed efficiently.
• Data Porting: When you need to port data from one format to another (e.g., from CSV to Excel, from SQL to Excel).

Code Comparison

Reading Data: OpenPyXL

from openpyxl import load_workbook

wb = load_workbook("data.xlsx")
ws = wb.active

for row in ws.iter_rows(min_col=1, max_col=2):
    print(row)

Reading Data: Pandas

import pandas as pd

df = pd.read_excel("data.xlsx")
print(df.head())

Data Analysis and Manipulation

Data Analysis with OpenPyXL

from openpyxl import load_workbook

# Load the workbook and get the active sheet
wb = load_workbook('data.xlsx')
ws = wb.active

# Create a list to store filtered data
filtered_data = []

# Loop through rows and filter data (Age > 25)
for row in ws.iter_rows(min_row=2, min_col=1, max_col=2):
    name, age = row[0].value, row[1].value
    if age > 25:
        filtered_data.append((name, age))

# Display the filtered data
for entry in filtered_data:
    print(entry)

Data Analysis with Pandas

import pandas as pd

# Load the data into a DataFrame
df = pd.read_excel('data.xlsx')

# Filter rows where Age > 25
filtered_df = df[df['Age'] > 25]

# Group by 'Age' and calculate the average Score for each group
grouped_df = filtered_df.groupby('Age')['Score'].mean()

# Display the grouped data
print(grouped_df)

Which One is Better for Data Porting and Analysis?

When working with Excel files in Python, the choice between OpenPyXL and Pandas often comes down to the specific task you're trying to accomplish. While both libraries can be used to read and write Excel files, they are optimized for different types of tasks. OpenPyXL is best suited for handling Excel-specific features like formatting, charts, and worksheets, while Pandas excels in data manipulation, analysis, and handling large datasets. Let’s compare their capabilities based on data porting and analysis tasks.

Code Samples: Data Porting and Analysis

Example 1: Reading Data

OpenPyXL reads Excel files by accessing cells directly, making it ideal for small, specific tasks but less efficient for large datasets. Here's how to load an Excel file using OpenPyXL and print the contents of a cell:

from openpyxl import load_workbook

# Load workbook and select the active worksheet
wb = load_workbook('data.xlsx')
ws = wb.active

# Accessing a cell and printing its value
print(ws['A1'].value)

Pandas provides a more efficient way to load data from Excel files and perform complex operations like filtering and aggregation:

import pandas as pd

# Load the data into a DataFrame
df = pd.read_excel('data.xlsx')

# Display the first few rows
print(df.head())

Example 2: Writing Data

OpenPyXL is perfect when you need to write data with specific formatting or Excel features. Here's how you can write data to Excel with cell styles:

from openpyxl import Workbook
from openpyxl.styles import Font

# Create a new workbook and worksheet
wb = Workbook()
ws = wb.active

# Write data and apply a style
ws['A1'] = "Hello, World!"
ws['A1'].font = Font(size=14, bold=True)

# Save the workbook
wb.save("styled_example.xlsx")

Pandas, on the other hand, is optimized for writing structured data (e.g., tables) to Excel, but it lacks the detailed formatting options that OpenPyXL offers:

# Write a DataFrame to Excel
df.to_excel('output.xlsx', index=False)

Comparison Table: OpenPyXL vs Pandas

Conclusion

• For Data Porting & Analysis: Pandas is better. It is designed for large datasets, fast data manipulation, and complex analysis. If your focus is on reading, cleaning, transforming, and analyzing data, Pandas is the go-to library.
• For Excel-Specific Features (Formatting, Charts, etc.): OpenPyXL is better. If your main goal is to create or modify Excel files with specific Excel-centric features (like formatting, charts, and images), OpenPyXL is more suitable.

Subhendu Mohapatra

Author

🎥 Join me live on YouTube

Passionate about coding and teaching, I publish practical tutorials on PHP, Python, JavaScript, SQL, and web development. My goal is to make learning simple, engaging, and project‑oriented with real examples and source code.

← Subscribe to our YouTube Channel here